Skip to main content

Facing Uncertainty

March 12, 2026

Here is how it has gone with deadly regularity throughout human history.

1. We humans exist in uncertainty, facing questions for which there are no clear-cut, obviously correct answers.

2. We humans do not take well to mystery, so we quickly migrate from uncertainty to certainty. We now have answers. (Consider, for example, the rich variety of creation myths that have arisen from peoples across the globe.)

3. The greater the uncertainty, the more certainties it will give birth to. Existence is the greatest uncertainty of them all, and from it have sprung the rich and often conflicting religions of the world. The deadliness of their wars of certainty versus certainty has been well chronicled; and the irony of all that murder and devastation is that if we could get beneath our arrogance and righteousness, we would be faced with the reality that none of us really knows what we are talking about. It is beyond our limited imaginations.

PAUSE: It is at this point that I can be accused of joining the war against people of faith, or equally as assaulting the sometimes smug certainty of science. My issue is with neither-I consider myself to be both a deeply spiritual person and a scientist-my focus is on the phenomenon of certainty.

4. Since certainty is a defense against uncertainty, we are very sensitive to having our certainty questioned. Thoughtful questioning threatens to cast us back into the abyss.

5. Try as we may, there is no escaping uncertainty. No sooner do we find comfort in a belief system, than uncertainties arise within it. Four examples, more later.

I. Reza Aslan, in No god but God, maintains that the real Islamic jihad is not against the West but is a longstanding struggle between the Rationalists and the Traditionalists. Both camps accepted the Koran as the word of God, but the Rationalists treated the meaning as changing over time, while, for the Traditionalists, the meaning was fixed and eternal. The current form of the struggle, according to Mr. Aslan, is between the Reformers and the Reactionaries. The Traditionalists/ Reactionaries won the battle and are still the dominant force in Islam.

II. Elaine Pagels, in Beyond Belief, describes similar internal struggles in the early days of Christianity; for example, the conflict between those who sought revelation through spiritual intuition-epinoia-and those who chose to rely on traditional sources of revelation. What conflict was only settled with the emperor Constantine's charge to the bishops to work out a standard formulation of the Christian faith. Very quickly, epinoia became heresy. That conflict, too, carries forth into the present with those who take the Bible as the fixed and eternal message of God, and those who believe, as a banner on my neighborhood church proclaims, "God is still speaking."

III. Within Judaism there has been a similar historic internal conflict that carries forth to today between those who adhere to the laws as detailed in the Torah and those who adapt the teachings to changing times. As divergent as these camps are in belief and behavior, both feel firmly grounded in Judaism.

IV. In our Merging Cultures Workshop, one culture with its cultural norms enters another culture with very different cultural norms. With great regularity, within both cultures, a tension develops between those who want to preserve their culture intact and those who are willing to allow in or adapt to the culture of the other. And once again, this is a struggle within cultures. In the larger society, this same tension between Preserve/Protect and Allow/Adapt is reflected in the "culture wars."

To be continued...

Leave a comment

You are commenting as guest.