Skip to main content

Radical Fringe

March 17, 2026

I'm re-posting this from 2010.

Theodore Roosevelt said, "Every reform movement has a lunatic fringe," and I have been taken to task for paying too much attention to the Tea Party's lunatic fringe-guns, hate, threats, comparisons to Hitler and Nazism, slippery slopes to Communism, racial and homophobic slurs, physical attacks-and not enough to the reasoned economic and political concerns of the party’s mainstream. A fair criticism. And it's true, I have no fear of rational discussion. We raise consciousness through protest and counter protest; we debate, we decide, we vote. But I do fear, with good historical evidence, the power of emotional appeals. The lunatic fringe is either admissible side show destined to fade in the face of rational deliberation, or it is the emotional seed of a growing populist movement. Hans Fallada, in "Every Man Dies Alone," takes note of Germans who saw Hitler and the rising Nazi party as a side show that couldn't possibly take hold in such a civilized country, yet, in the end, the fringe became mainstream not because of its rational arguments but because of its emotional appeal-our greatness, the polluting effects of the Other, a leader with a simple solution to extremely complex issues, frustrations with handy targets to blame. So, while the rational issues are being debated, I'll keep my eye on the lunatic fringe.

Leave a comment

You are commenting as guest.